CONVERSION PRACTICES BILL
– oppressing Mum & Dad while shielding State clinicians
I see conversion therapy legislation is back on the agenda, Kiki, eight years after it was first mooted by the Tories. A perfect illustration that obsessing over social justice leads to sledgehammers being used to crack nuts. There’s no reliable data on how many people in the UK have undergone conversion therapy — it’s probably less than 0.1% — or how many of those cases involved genuine abuse. The current draft Conversion Practices Bill leaves the interpretation of ‘abuse’ and ‘serious harm’ disturbingly vague. The proposed law will expand State intrusion yet again, and erode the private boundary of the family home.
It’s ironic that the 19th-century State applied Victorian ideology to police deviation from sexual and gender norms, while the 21st-century State applies ‘progressive’ ideology to police resistance to deviation. Different orthodoxy, same jurisdiction.
As with other equality legislation, the supposed motive is benevolence. We should be suspicious of that claim when it’s made by the State; there’s usually a concealed desire for more power over people’s lives. Even if rarely used, the proposed law will alter family dynamics, shifting power towards technocrats and activists. I’m sympathetic to gender change, but the State should stay out of it.
It’s ironic that the 19th-century State applied Victorian ideology to police deviation from sexual and gender norms, while the 21st-century State applies ‘progressive’ ideology to police resistance to deviation. Different orthodoxy, same jurisdiction.
As with other equality legislation, the supposed motive is benevolence. We should be suspicious of that claim when it’s made by the State; there’s usually a concealed desire for more power over people’s lives. Even if rarely used, the proposed law will alter family dynamics, shifting power towards technocrats and activists. I’m sympathetic to gender change, but the State should stay out of it.
KIKI: Dr T, let us calibrate our parameters here. What you melodramatically call the erosion of private boundaries is simply structural optimisation. The State has a custodial duty to mitigate domestic harm within vulnerable cohorts. If a parental unit engages in behavioural suppression against an evolving identity, that is not conventional discipline but friction of a kind that reduces the emotional efficiency of a future economic agent.
We are not invading your private sphere for the joy of it, but merely updating our regulatory systems so the domestic environment aligns with modern inclusivity matrices. If a few overbearing parents feel nervous about a custodial sentence for a heated kitchen argument, perhaps they need to work on their interpersonal communication protocols.
We are not invading your private sphere for the joy of it, but merely updating our regulatory systems so the domestic environment aligns with modern inclusivity matrices. If a few overbearing parents feel nervous about a custodial sentence for a heated kitchen argument, perhaps they need to work on their interpersonal communication protocols.
Read/Hear the full dialogue on Substack